UHBUHB
Jurnal Hukum In ConcretoJurnal Hukum In ConcretoThis research aims to analyze the forms of judicial inconsistency in sentencing theft cases, particularly those involving juvenile offenders, and to identify the contributing factors within Indonesias criminal justice framework. Sentencing disparity often raises serious concerns regarding substantive justice and legal certainty, especially when two cases with nearly identical legal elements and factual backgrounds result in significantly different judgments. This study employs a normative juridical method combined with a case study approach, focusing on two court decisions: Number 14/Pid.B/2011/PN.Yk and Number 10/Pid.SUS-Anak/2015/PN.Yk. Data were collected from statutory instruments, court documents, and judicial reasoning, and analyzed through both normative and sociological lenses. The findings reveal that judicial inconsistency stems from differences in the legal basis applied by judges, the social backgrounds of the offenders, and the uneven consideration of social inquiry reports. Moreover, the unregulated scope of judicial discretion due to the absence of standardized sentencing guidelines has significantly contributed to these disparities. When sentencing is not grounded in clear legal, sociological, and philosophical justification, the ruling loses its legitimacy and may erode public trust in the justice system. This study emphasizes the urgent need for a national sentencing guideline to ensure more consistent, transparent, and accountable sentencing practices within Indonesias legal system, particularly in cases involving vulnerable groups such as juveniles.
The study reveals that judicial inconsistency in theft sentencing, particularly involving juvenile offenders, arises from divergent normative approaches, variations in the offenders social background, and inconsistent application of legal and social assessment instruments.This inconsistency stems from the absence of standardized sentencing guidelines, unregulated judicial discretion, and uneven consideration of social inquiry reports.Establishing a binding and standardized sentencing guideline, strengthening the role of Social Probation Officers, and providing continuous training for judges are crucial steps to address this issue and ensure a fairer and more transparent justice system.
Further research should investigate the effectiveness of restorative justice practices in reducing sentencing disparities for juvenile theft cases, exploring how community-based rehabilitation programs can be integrated into the sentencing process. Additionally, a comparative study examining sentencing guidelines in other jurisdictions with similar legal systems could provide valuable insights for developing a national sentencing framework tailored to the Indonesian context. Finally, research is needed to assess the impact of judicial training programs on reducing subjective biases and promoting consistent application of legal principles in sentencing decisions, focusing on the development of standardized evaluation methods for social inquiry reports and offender risk assessments.
- A Normative Analysis of Juvenile Sentencing Laws in Indonesia: Reconciling Justice, Rehabilitation, and... doi.org/10.33258/polit.v3i3.969A Normative Analysis of Juvenile Sentencing Laws in Indonesia Reconciling Justice Rehabilitation and doi 10 33258 polit v3i3 969
- Implementing Restorative Justice Under the Retributive Paradigm: A Pilot Program Case Study - Patrick... doi.org/10.1177/2158244017691562Implementing Restorative Justice Under the Retributive Paradigm A Pilot Program Case Study Patrick doi 10 1177 2158244017691562
- Disparitas Hukuman dalam Perkara Pidana Pencurian dengan Pemberatan Putusan Nomor. 782/PID.B/2019/PN.Smg... doi.org/10.58222/juruh.v3i1.772Disparitas Hukuman dalam Perkara Pidana Pencurian dengan Pemberatan Putusan Nomor 782 PID B 2019 PN Smg doi 10 58222 juruh v3i1 772
| File size | 429.69 KB |
| Pages | 13 |
| DMCA | Report |
Related /
UMPOUMPO Trial data collected by document analysis, interviews, and administration of the validator and student questionnaires, then analyzed using qualitativeTrial data collected by document analysis, interviews, and administration of the validator and student questionnaires, then analyzed using qualitative
UIN ANTASARIUIN ANTASARI Perlindungan hukum PMI harus dibangun sebagai sistem terpadu yang meliputi pencegahan, bantuan hukum, dan dukungan pascapersidangan agar kewajiban konstitusionalPerlindungan hukum PMI harus dibangun sebagai sistem terpadu yang meliputi pencegahan, bantuan hukum, dan dukungan pascapersidangan agar kewajiban konstitusional
LPPM UNASMANLPPM UNASMAN Kegiatan pendampingan Pusat Kegiatan Belajar Masyarakat (PKBM) Wahyuri di Desa Kenje Kecamatan Campalagian bertujuan meningkatkan partisipasi sosial danKegiatan pendampingan Pusat Kegiatan Belajar Masyarakat (PKBM) Wahyuri di Desa Kenje Kecamatan Campalagian bertujuan meningkatkan partisipasi sosial dan
STHBSTHB It advocates for the development of a legal system adaptable to the challenges of overcapacity in correctional institutions, promoting a balance betweenIt advocates for the development of a legal system adaptable to the challenges of overcapacity in correctional institutions, promoting a balance between
UNIRA MALANGUNIRA MALANG The research results show that 1). The formulation of learning objectives uses learning achievement (CP) references developed in learning objectives withThe research results show that 1). The formulation of learning objectives uses learning achievement (CP) references developed in learning objectives with
UNHASUNHAS Selain itu, dengan adanya data geospasial terintegrasi, data tersebut dapat digunakan sebagai alat dalam formulasi kebijakan, pengambilan keputusan, dan/atauSelain itu, dengan adanya data geospasial terintegrasi, data tersebut dapat digunakan sebagai alat dalam formulasi kebijakan, pengambilan keputusan, dan/atau
UNHASUNHAS Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa regulasi pertambangan saat ini masih belum mencerminkan pengakuan dan perlindungan hak masyarakat adat. Diperlukan penyempurnaanHasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa regulasi pertambangan saat ini masih belum mencerminkan pengakuan dan perlindungan hak masyarakat adat. Diperlukan penyempurnaan
MKRIMKRI Mahkamah dalam pertimbangan putusannya telah berhasil mengelaborasikan kepentingan hukum dengan metode penafsiran yang tepat sehingga menghasilkan terobosanMahkamah dalam pertimbangan putusannya telah berhasil mengelaborasikan kepentingan hukum dengan metode penafsiran yang tepat sehingga menghasilkan terobosan
Useful /
UNHASAUNHASA Kabupaten Probolinggo menempati urutan kedua kasus TB tertinggi di Jawa Timur. Hingga 18 Maret 2025, dari target 16.466 terduga, ditemukan 3. 532 kasusKabupaten Probolinggo menempati urutan kedua kasus TB tertinggi di Jawa Timur. Hingga 18 Maret 2025, dari target 16.466 terduga, ditemukan 3. 532 kasus
UNHASUNHAS Sebaliknya, banyak pihak berwenang di AS memiliki fleksibilitas untuk mengadopsi peraturan yang memastikan penggunaan mata uang kripto secara legal. SejalanSebaliknya, banyak pihak berwenang di AS memiliki fleksibilitas untuk mengadopsi peraturan yang memastikan penggunaan mata uang kripto secara legal. Sejalan
UNSUNS Kolaborasi tersebut diproyeksikan dapat meningkatkan kesejahteraan masyarakat Maluku melalui penyerapan tenaga kerja, pertumbuhan ekonomi regional, peningkatanKolaborasi tersebut diproyeksikan dapat meningkatkan kesejahteraan masyarakat Maluku melalui penyerapan tenaga kerja, pertumbuhan ekonomi regional, peningkatan
UNSUNS Industri kreatif mengalami kemajuan yang sangat pesat, seiring dengan perkembangan industri pariwisata yang dapat diandalkan tidak hanya untuk membukaIndustri kreatif mengalami kemajuan yang sangat pesat, seiring dengan perkembangan industri pariwisata yang dapat diandalkan tidak hanya untuk membuka