IAI TABAHIAI TABAH
Madinah: Jurnal Studi IslamMadinah: Jurnal Studi IslamThis study reconstructs the methodological hierarchy for resolving apparent contradictions (taʿāruḍ al-adillah) within Islamic legal sources. It critically argues that the theories of nasikh-mansūkh (abrogation) and tarjīḥ (preferential weighting) are often prioritized disproportionately. Through theoretical examination and in-depth case studies, this research positions both theories as ultimum remedium (last resort), while asserting harmonization methods. This qualitative research with a descriptive-analytical approach utilizes primary data from the works of classical and contemporary scholars. The principle is tested through three critical case studies: the controversy over abrogation claims regarding peace-war verses, claims of contradiction between mutashābih hadiths and the Quran, and claims of abrogation concerning the hadith about a deceased person being tormented due to their familys weeping. The analysis confirms that genuine contradiction within revelation is impossible. The three case studies prove that existing contradictions are apparent (ẓāhirī) and can be resolved through semantic harmonization and contextual understanding. For example, the relationship between peace and war verses is explained by dynamic contextualization (munsaʾ), not permanent abrogation. In the case of the hadiths, the approaches of taʾwīl (figurative interpretation) and al-jamʿu prove effective in reconciling the texts. In conclusion, nasikh-mansūkh and tarjīḥ should serve as mechanisms of last resort, to be employed only after all efforts at harmonization and contextual interpretation have been exhausted. This article offers a methodological reconstruction in uṣūl al-fiqh by providing a clear hierarchy, challenging hasty conventional applications, and advocating for a paradigm that ensures the unity and contextual wisdom of the Shariah.
The research affirms a reorientation of the methodological hierarchy in responding to seemingly contradictory scriptural evidence, prioritizing reconciliation (al-jamu) and contextualization (al-munasabah wa al-munsa).Nasikh-mansukh and tarjih should be considered emergency solutions or last resorts, employed only after exhaustive harmonization efforts.This approach preserves the unity of revelation and ensures a comprehensive understanding of Islamic law.The study demonstrates that apparent contradictions can be resolved through careful analysis, contextual understanding, and appropriate interpretation, upholding the coherence and wisdom of Sharia.
Further research should explore the application of the munsa concept in contemporary legal issues, particularly in areas where conflicting interpretations of Islamic texts lead to practical disputes. Additionally, a comparative study examining how different schools of thought within Islamic jurisprudence approach the hierarchy of resolving conflicting evidence could reveal nuanced perspectives and potential areas of convergence. Finally, investigating the role of historical context and the socio-political factors influencing the development of nasikh-mansukh and tarjih theories would provide a deeper understanding of their evolution and relevance in modern times. These investigations should move beyond theoretical discussions and focus on practical case studies, analyzing real-world legal challenges and proposing innovative solutions grounded in a robust understanding of usul al-fiqh. Such research could also benefit from incorporating insights from modern linguistic analysis and hermeneutics to refine the methods of textual interpretation and reconciliation. Ultimately, these studies aim to strengthen the foundations of Islamic legal reasoning and promote a more nuanced and contextually sensitive application of Sharia in the 21st century, fostering greater clarity and consistency in legal rulings while upholding the core principles of justice and equity. The exploration of these areas will contribute to a more dynamic and responsive Islamic legal system capable of addressing the complex challenges of the modern world.
- Diskursus Nāsikh-Mansūkh dalam Perspektif Ulama Klasik dan Kontemporer | Canonia Religia. diskursus... doi.org/10.30762/cr.v1i2.2667Diskursus NAsikh Manskh dalam Perspektif Ulama Klasik dan Kontemporer Canonia Religia diskursus doi 10 30762 cr v1i2 2667
- UNDERSTANDING OF THE AYNA ALLAH HADITH: AN INTERDISCIPLINARY TAḤLĪLĪ STUDY | Azhary | Nabawi: Journal... doi.org/10.55987/njhs.v5i2.156UNDERSTANDING OF THE AYNA ALLAH HADITH AN INTERDISCIPLINARY TALL STUDY Azhary Nabawi Journal doi 10 55987 njhs v5i2 156
- THE STUDY OF MISREPRESENTED HADITHS ON THE INTERNET ABOUT MUSLIM AND NON-MUSLIM RELATIONSHIPS | Haq |... doi.org/10.55987/njhs.v4i1.97THE STUDY OF MISREPRESENTED HADITHS ON THE INTERNET ABOUT MUSLIM AND NON MUSLIM RELATIONSHIPS Haq doi 10 55987 njhs v4i1 97
| File size | 549.46 KB |
| Pages | 12 |
| DMCA | Report |
Related /
DAARULHUDADAARULHUDA Fenomena ini tidak hanya berdampak pada korban secara fisik, tetapi juga menimbulkan trauma psikologis, kerugian sosial, serta gangguan stabilitas keluarga.Fenomena ini tidak hanya berdampak pada korban secara fisik, tetapi juga menimbulkan trauma psikologis, kerugian sosial, serta gangguan stabilitas keluarga.
DAARULHUDADAARULHUDA Penelitian ini menyimpulkan bahwa penguatan maqaṣid al-syarīah dalam regulasi dan praktik peradilan merupakan langkah strategis untuk membangun sistemPenelitian ini menyimpulkan bahwa penguatan maqaṣid al-syarīah dalam regulasi dan praktik peradilan merupakan langkah strategis untuk membangun sistem
PERADABANPUBLISHINGPERADABANPUBLISHING Kepemilikan harta dipandang sebagai sarana untuk mewujudkan kemakmuran bersama dan mengatasi ketimpangan sosial, dengan penekanan pada keseimbangan antaraKepemilikan harta dipandang sebagai sarana untuk mewujudkan kemakmuran bersama dan mengatasi ketimpangan sosial, dengan penekanan pada keseimbangan antara
PERADABANPUBLISHINGPERADABANPUBLISHING Both figures offer a reconstruction of Islamic education that is critical and based on Islamic values. Ultimately, both have made strategic contributionsBoth figures offer a reconstruction of Islamic education that is critical and based on Islamic values. Ultimately, both have made strategic contributions
PERADABANPUBLISHINGPERADABANPUBLISHING Istilah insān menggambarkan manusia sebagai makhluk yang lemah dan pelupa, basyar menekankan aspek biologis, an‑nās menunjukkan manusia sebagai makhlukIstilah insān menggambarkan manusia sebagai makhluk yang lemah dan pelupa, basyar menekankan aspek biologis, an‑nās menunjukkan manusia sebagai makhluk
PERADABANPUBLISHINGPERADABANPUBLISHING Informan dipilih secara purposive berdasarkan konsistensi berhijab, keterlibatan keagamaan, dan aktivitas media sosial. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwaInforman dipilih secara purposive berdasarkan konsistensi berhijab, keterlibatan keagamaan, dan aktivitas media sosial. Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa
PERADABANPUBLISHINGPERADABANPUBLISHING Sexual violence remains a persistent challenge in university environments, despite the implementation of various policies and task forces, including atSexual violence remains a persistent challenge in university environments, despite the implementation of various policies and task forces, including at
PERADABANPUBLISHINGPERADABANPUBLISHING 102 mencerminkan tiga dimensi keterlibatan ayah menurut Michael E. Lamb—engagement, accessibility, dan responsibility—melalui dialog, kehadiran emosional,102 mencerminkan tiga dimensi keterlibatan ayah menurut Michael E. Lamb—engagement, accessibility, dan responsibility—melalui dialog, kehadiran emosional,
Useful /
DAARULHUDADAARULHUDA Penetapan batas usia minimal dalam proses rekrutmen tenaga kerja merupakan praktik yang umum diterapkan oleh perusahaan di Indonesia. Kebijakan ini seringPenetapan batas usia minimal dalam proses rekrutmen tenaga kerja merupakan praktik yang umum diterapkan oleh perusahaan di Indonesia. Kebijakan ini sering
LMULMU A pre-experimental design with a one-group pretest-posttest approach and a quantitative method was used. Data were analyzed using the Wilcoxon Signed RankA pre-experimental design with a one-group pretest-posttest approach and a quantitative method was used. Data were analyzed using the Wilcoxon Signed Rank
PNCPNC Objek wisata yang ditawarkan adalah Tubing, Curug Pangasinan, Bukit Pengkol, dan Tilik Alas. Sebelum adanya website ini, promosi hanya dilakukan di mediaObjek wisata yang ditawarkan adalah Tubing, Curug Pangasinan, Bukit Pengkol, dan Tilik Alas. Sebelum adanya website ini, promosi hanya dilakukan di media
PNCPNC Harapannya setelah pelatihan ini, pihak Charu Dhatri dapat meningkatkan penggunaan sosial media sehingga memberikan dampak positif terhadap penjualan.Harapannya setelah pelatihan ini, pihak Charu Dhatri dapat meningkatkan penggunaan sosial media sehingga memberikan dampak positif terhadap penjualan.