Publisher

UNEJUNEJ

Journal Journal of Southeast Asian Human RightsJournal of Southeast Asian Human Rights Abstract

Multiculturalism has increasingly been identified with ethno-religious identities in recent years. Multiple authors paraphrase the interaction of multiculturalism and secularism as “moderate secularism, which emphasizes equal status of the majority and minority religions. This study widens the scope and compares to what degree Western and non-Western Muslim states allow religious minority groups to co-exist with the majority religions. Three European and three non-Western countries are included in the study based on a review of national policies and practices around secularism, analyzed through Modoods framework of moderate secularism. This study finds that the position of minority religions is generally weakened in all the countries, with strong political tensions between different religious groups. While the European countries continue to assess the position of minority religion from a secular perspective, strengthening Christian identity, non-Western countries with strong Islamic constituencies gain more influence in political processes. This study also concludes that Modoods model of moderate secularism is flawed, as it does not take into account political realities and public attitudes.

Conclusion

The practice of secularism varies significantly between European and Muslim countries, influenced by historical, political, and cultural factors.The convergence of secularism and multiculturalism, as initially proposed, is not evident in the studied cases, with increasing tensions between religious groups.Modoods model of moderate secularism proves inadequate due to its failure to account for political realities and public attitudes, particularly the influence of majority religions and the challenges faced by minority religions.

Future Research

Further research should investigate the specific mechanisms through which national identities are constructed and how these constructions impact the integration of religious minorities. A comparative study of educational systems in these countries could reveal how religious curricula and policies contribute to or mitigate interreligious tensions. Additionally, exploring the role of civil society organizations in promoting interfaith dialogue and fostering inclusive policies is crucial, particularly in contexts where state-led initiatives are limited or biased. These investigations should move beyond policy analysis to incorporate qualitative data capturing the lived experiences of individuals from diverse religious backgrounds, providing a more nuanced understanding of the challenges and opportunities for peaceful coexistence.

References

1. Values Education or Religious Education? An Alternative View of Religious Education in the Secular Age,... doi.org/10.3390/educsci8040220Values Education or Religious Education An Alternative View of Religious Education in the Secular Age doi 10 3390 educsci8040220
2. Validate User. validate user sorry experiencing unusual traffic time please help confirm robot take content... academic.oup.com/crawlprevention/governor?content=/CustomError?statusCode=404&404;academic.oup.com:80/crawlprevention/governor?content=/CustomError?statusCode=404&404;academic.oup.com:80/crawlprevention/governor?content=/CustomError?statusCode=404&404;academic.oup.com:80/crawlprevention/governor?content=/CustomError?statusCode=404&404;academic.oup.com:80/crawlprevention/governor?content=/CustomError?statusCode=404&404;academic.oup.com:80/crawlprevention/governor?content=/CustomError?statusCode=404&404;academic.oup.com:80/crawlprevention/governor?content=/edited-volume/28028/chapter/211850554Validate User validate user sorry experiencing unusual traffic time please help confirm robot take content academic oup crawlprevention governor content CustomError statusCode 404 404 academic oup 80 crawlprevention governor content CustomError statusCode 404 404 academic oup 80 crawlprevention governor content CustomError statusCode 404 404 academic oup 80 crawlprevention governor content CustomError statusCode 404 404 academic oup 80 crawlprevention governor content CustomError statusCode 404 404 academic oup 80 crawlprevention governor content CustomError statusCode 404 404 academic oup 80 crawlprevention governor content edited volume 28028 chapter 211850554
3. The Evolution of the Concept of Secularism Towards its Encounter with Multiculturalism | Viktorahadi... journal.uinsgd.ac.id/index.php/jis/article/view/15034The Evolution of the Concept of Secularism Towards its Encounter with Multiculturalism Viktorahadi journal uinsgd ac index php jis article view 15034
4. Analysing the State’s Laws on Religious Education in Post-New Order Indonesia | Yusuf | Al-Jami'ah:... doi.org/10.14421/ajis.2015.531.105-130Analysing the StateAos Laws on Religious Education in Post New Order Indonesia Yusuf Al Jamiah doi 10 14421 ajis 2015 531 105 130

Subjects

1. #civil society#civil society
2. #information search#information search

Metadata

File size	742 KB
Pages	32
Short Link	https://juris.id/p-r4
Lookup Links	Google ScholarGoogle Scholar, Semantic ScholarSemantic Scholar, CORE.ac.ukCORE.ac.uk, WorldcatWorldcat, ZenodoZenodo, Research GateResearch Gate, Academia.eduAcademia.edu, OpenAlexOpenAlex, Hollis HarvardHollis Harvard
DMCA	Report